Whether trademarks containing dates that suggest a founding year can be misleading, under Turkish law and in the Fauré Le Page case.
I. Introduction
Using date elements as part of a trademark has become an important strategy for steering consumer perception. Date elements often appear in trademarks as indications of the business’s founding year, since a long-established history is regarded as strengthening consumers’ perception of trust and quality.
But is it misleading to use, as an element of a trademark, a year that differs from the brand’s actual founding date? In this article, we examine whether a trademark containing a date that is unrelated to the history of the business but may be perceived as its founding year is misleading, in light of Turkish trademark law and the “Fauré Le Page” case pending before the French Court of Cassation.
II. What Is a Misleading Sign Under Industrial Property Law No. 6769?
Trademarks are signs that distinguish the goods or services of one undertaking from those of other undertakings. The range of signs that can constitute a trademark under Turkish law is very broad: words, figures, numbers, sounds and colour combinations, among many others, may be registered as trademarks. However, a trademark application must not be refused on absolute or relative grounds in order to be registered.
Under Article 5(1)(f) of Industrial Property Law No. 6769 (IPL), which sets out the absolute grounds for refusal, “signs which are of such a nature as to deceive the public*, for instance as to the nature, quality or geographical origin of the goods or services”* cannot be registered as trademarks. The same rule is found in Article 7 of EU Trade Mark Regulation No. 2015/2424 and in Section 8 of the German Trade Mark Act. The key question is whether the sign is liable to mislead the average consumer.
A sign is considered misleading where there is an “actual and sufficiently serious” risk that consumers will be deceived as to the nature and characteristics of the goods. A mere remote possibility is not sufficient.
It is accepted that deception may arise under three main headings:
-
deception as to the “nature” of the goods or services,
-
deception as to the “quality” of the goods or services,
-
deception as to the “geographical origin” of the goods or services.
Because of the words “for instance” in the provision, deception is not limited to these headings. Moreover, Article 5(1)(f) IPL essentially aims to protect consumers who purchase the goods or services bearing the trademark, as well as the public interest. It follows that signs which are misleading in respects similar to, but other than, the nature, quality or geographical origin of the goods or services cannot be registered as trademarks either.
III. Are Trademarks Containing Dates That May Be Perceived as a Founding Year Misleading?
When examining trademark applications, the Turkish Patent and Trademark Office (TÜRKPATENT) is not required to verify the nature or accuracy of a date in the mark, or whether the applicant’s business was actually founded on that date. However, where an applicant includes in its mark a date that does not indicate its founding year or any other characteristic of its business, thereby creating the impression of a long-established history, the question arises whether the mark is misleading. In this context, it is highly important whether marks containing dates that create a false perception of the historical origins of the business should be refused under the absolute ground in Article 5(1)(f) IPL, and whether such marks, if registered, may later be declared invalid.
First, under Article 5(1)(f) IPL, signs liable to mislead the public as to the nature of the goods or services cannot be registered. It is open to debate whether the date since which the goods or services have been offered, or since which the business offering them has been active, and whether the business is long-established, relate to the nature of the goods or services. If this is considered part of the nature of the goods or services, then under the express wording of Article 5(1)(f) IPL, signs misleading the public in this respect, that is, signs containing misleading indications of a founding date or of the date on which the goods or services were first offered, cannot be registered as trademarks.
Furthermore, as explained above, the cases of deception listed in Article 5(1)(f) IPL are not limited to the nature, quality or geographical origin of the goods or services. Signs that mislead the public in similar respects cannot be registered either. A trademark that gives false information about the history of the business may mislead consumers, lead them to a different perception of the goods or services and prevent them from making a choice that reflects their true intentions.
In our opinion, where elements that will clearly be perceived as dates are used in a trademark in a way that gives the impression of a long-established business although the applicant has no such history, the mark should be assessed for deceptiveness, and the application should be refused if there is an actual and sufficiently serious risk that the public will be misled.
IV. The Fauré Le Page Case and Its Background
The Fauré Le Page case, which addresses this very issue, is currently pending in France. The case concerns the “Fauré Le Page” trademark. The company “Maison Fauré Le Page”, first founded in Paris in 1716, traded in weapons, ammunition and leather accessories. That company was dissolved in 1992 and ceased its activities. In 2009, however, a new company named “Fauré Le Page Paris” was founded with no legal or corporate connection to the former company. The new entity began operating in luxury leather goods and soon registered two trademarks containing the words “Fauré Le Page Paris 1717”. This led the claimant to seek revocation of the marks on the ground that they were misleading. The claimant argues that the element “1717” added to the marks creates a false perception among consumers that the company has a long history and gives the impression that the new company is the successor of the former brand. The case therefore raises the question whether a trademark containing an old date unrelated to the founding of the brand is misleading.
A. The Legal Debate and the Positions of the Parties
Two main positions have emerged in the proceedings:
- The claimant and the French Court of Cassation: The competing company and the French Court of Cassation argue that the deceptiveness of a trademark is not limited to the characteristics of the goods or services, but may also extend to elements such as the identity and history of the trademark owner.
- The trademark owner’s defence: The trademark owner argues that the court should focus directly on the characteristics of the goods and services rather than on the identity of the trademark owner. It supports this position by referring to the decision of the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) of 27 November 2019 (No. 19646) on a similar issue, which held that the mark was not deceptive.
B. The Court’s Referral to the CJEU
Rather than issuing a final decision, the French Court of Cassation has made a request for a preliminary ruling to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) on how the relevant provisions of Directive 2008/95/EC of 22 October 2008 should be interpreted. The CJEU decision, expected in the coming months, is of great importance not only for this case but also for similar trademarks. We will follow the CJEU decision with interest, particularly for a clearer framework on the use of dates in trademark registration and for clarification of which elements should be taken into account in assessing deceptiveness.
V. Conclusion
The inclusion in a trademark of date elements that create a perception not reflecting the true history or founding year of the brand may lead to refusal of the application, or invalidation of the registered mark, on the ground that it is misleading. Under Article 5(1)(f) IPL, signs that mislead the public cannot be registered as trademarks. The provision expressly lists deception as to the nature, quality and geographical origin of goods and services, but the words “for instance” make clear that its scope is not limited to these. In the “Fauré Le Page” case, the French Court of Cassation has requested a preliminary ruling from the CJEU, and the decision will be of great importance for the deceptiveness of trademarks containing dates and for the assessment of deceptiveness in general. The referral is expected to lay the groundwork for a clearer legal framework in this area and to guide future trademark registration practice. We will follow the decision with interest.
This article is for general information only. The outcome of a specific matter may vary depending on its facts.




