The legal framework for remote healthcare in Türkiye, uses of AI, information obligations and sanctions.
Introduction
Rapid developments in information and communication technologies have led to the diversification of healthcare services, new initiatives to make services more accessible and new R&D work. In this context, healthcare delivered through technological means without requiring the patient and the physician to be in the same physical setting, known as “telemedicine”, is becoming increasingly widespread.
In Türkiye, the standards for telemedicine are set by the Regulation on the Provision of Remote Healthcare Services (the “Regulation”), published in the Official Gazette and entered into force on 10 February 2022. The Regulation contains comprehensive rules on many matters, including the qualifications required of institutions and healthcare personnel providing remote healthcare services and the scope of such services.
Nature of the Remote Healthcare Service Contract
Under the Regulation, a remote healthcare service contract can be defined as a contractual relationship between an authorised healthcare facility and a patient, under which the physician provides diagnosis or treatment through the remote health information system and the patient undertakes to pay a certain fee in return.
Under the definition of telemedicine adopted by the European Commission and the World Health Organization (WHO), communication between physicians is also considered telemedicine. The Regulation, however, only governs the relationship between the healthcare facility and the patient in what it calls remote healthcare services.
Healthcare Services That May Be Provided Through Telemedicine
Within the scope defined by the WHO, the following services may be provided to patients through telemedicine:
- Teleradiology: the use of digital radiological images for diagnosis or consultation,
- Teledermatology: the transmission of medical information on skin conditions for diagnosis or consultation,
- Telepathology: the transmission of digital pathological data, such as microscopic images of cells, for diagnosis or consultation,
- Telepsychiatry: the provision of remote mental health services,
- Monitoring (remote patient monitoring): the transmission of information on the condition of patients, often at home, to external monitoring centres by means of sensors and monitoring equipment.
In Türkiye, the healthcare services listed in Article 7 of the Regulation may be provided through telemedicine:
- A person requesting remote healthcare may be examined to the extent the remote service allows; the person’s medical observation, monitoring, follow-up and assessment may be carried out, diagnosed illnesses may be checked, medical advice may be given, and a consultation or second opinion may be requested. Where necessary, the person may be advised to physically visit a healthcare institution.
- For remote management and follow-up of illnesses, the person’s clinical parameters such as blood sugar and blood pressure may be assessed and monitored, and treatment and medication management may be provided.
- Services aimed at protecting and monitoring health, supporting a healthy life and providing psychosocial support may be offered.
- Comprehensive assessment and follow-up of persons with increased health risks or of advanced age may be carried out.
- Provided that technological capabilities allow and the necessary permissions are obtained from the Ministry, interventional or surgical procedures determined by the Ministry may be offered.
- In endemic or epidemic outbreaks, the necessary medical procedures to protect people’s health may be carried out in line with national guidelines.
- Health data of the person requesting healthcare may be measured and monitored through wearable technologies and other medical devices.
- The physician may issue e-prescriptions and e-reports for the person assessed.
In addition, medical procedures that do not involve direct physical intervention or contact, such as taking a medical history (anamnesis), psychiatric examination, assessment of tests, follow-up and monitoring, are also considered medical interventions within this scope.
Requirements for Facilities Providing Remote Healthcare
A healthcare facility wishing to provide remote healthcare services may obtain a remote healthcare service activity permit by applying to the provincial health directorate and meeting the necessary requirements.
State hospitals, private hospitals and university hospitals may obtain an activity permit.
The application must include the following in full:
- the licence, activity permit, registration certificate, certificate of conformity and similar permits relating to the opening and operation of the healthcare facility,
- documents showing the remote health information system the facility will use to provide remote healthcare,
- a list of the technological equipment the facility will use to provide remote healthcare,
- a list of the premises the facility allocates to remote healthcare,
- a list showing the name and surname, Turkish ID number or foreign ID number, title and specialty of the healthcare professionals who will provide remote healthcare at the facility,
- for facilities that will provide remote healthcare within the scope of international health tourism, a copy of the international health tourism authorisation certificate.
Remote Health Information System
Under Article 4/1-e of the Regulation, remote healthcare must be provided through the Remote Health Information System. Medical advice given through digital channels other than the remote health information system by a facility not authorised by the Ministry to provide remote healthcare, or by a physician personally, does not fall within this scope.
Uses of Artificial Intelligence in Telemedicine
1) Robotic Surgery
Surgical robots are one of the areas in which artificial intelligence is used in the healthcare sector. These systems can perform many operations, including laser eye surgery, hair transplants, urology, gynaecology, thoracic and cardiac surgery and knee replacements. Procedures can be carried out with AI-assisted surgical systems without the doctor being in the same place as the patient.
2) Physiotherapy and Prosthetics
Devices designed by combining AI algorithms with robotic hardware, generally used in the physiotherapy of patients who have lost muscle function due to conditions such as spinal cord injury or stroke, help patients exercise and walk without human intervention.
Artificial intelligence is also used in advanced prosthetics. Today’s technology has made possible advanced prostheses that become part of the patient’s body, work in coordination with their muscles and can be controlled by external signals.
3) Monitoring Patient Data and Test Results
For chronic conditions, doctors can access patient data through mobile devices and easily monitor and interpret test results even when they are not in the same place as the patient.
Likewise, in services requiring real-time monitoring of patient data, such as intensive care units, telemedicine enables efficient and effective real-time monitoring of many patients at the same time.
By using the possibilities offered by AI tools in the remote monitoring and interpretation of patient data, the needs of a large number of patients can be identified quickly and accurately.
4) Personalised Treatment and Home Care
For some conditions, treatment must be personalised because of factors such as the immune system or living conditions. In such cases, AI applications are used to develop tailored treatment methods. Artificial intelligence is also used to facilitate regular monitoring and on-demand home care for people with conditions such as Alzheimer’s disease and dementia.
Insurance Coverage of Telemedicine Services
The insurance coverage and reimbursement procedure for remote healthcare services are set out in the Health Implementation Communiqué (SUT) published by the Social Security Institution (SGK). With an amendment published in the Official Gazette of 21 April 2024, remote healthcare services were brought within the scope of the SUT.
Under SUT Article 2.2.1.B-4:
- Fees for healthcare services provided by all branches in remote patient assessment are invoiced under procedure code “520032 Healthcare services for remote patient assessment” in List EK-2/B annexed to the SUT.
- When provided by tertiary healthcare providers affiliated with the Ministry of Health, the service is invoiced at twice the point value of code “520032”. The Institution covers at most one “healthcare service for remote patient assessment” fee per day for the same patient at the same provider.
- If prescribed, medicines are obtained from contracted pharmacies.
- The number of “remote patient assessment” applications invoiced to the Institution may not exceed 15% of the provider’s total outpatient applications in all branches during the day, excluding emergency applications.
- If amounts in List EK-2/A annexed to the SUT have been invoiced for the patient’s earlier outpatient application to the same provider for the same specialty, excluding emergency applications, the “520032” procedure may not be invoiced for the same specialty within 10 days, including the day of the outpatient application.
- If the “520032” procedure has been invoiced for the patient’s earlier outpatient application to the same provider for the same specialty, excluding emergency applications, neither the “520032” procedure nor the amount in List EK-2/A may be invoiced for the same specialty within 10 days, including the day of the outpatient application.
- Only the fees of procedures included in the “List of Procedures to Be Additionally Invoiced in Outpatient Applications (EK-2/A-2)” annexed to the SUT may be invoiced.
Information Obligations in Remote Healthcare
1. Duty to Inform
The duty of the facility providing remote healthcare to inform the patient is set out in detail in Article 9 of the Regulation, entitled “Informing the patient”. Under this article, the patient must be informed of the identity and specialty of the healthcare professional; that the service will be provided without being in the same place; that it is not equivalent to face-to-face healthcare; that hands-on treatment and remote healthcare differ; that remote treatment cannot be applied in a way that disrupts ongoing treatment; that in an emergency the nearest emergency department should be visited; the fee; that audio and video recording is prohibited without the parties’ consent, but that personal information will be transferred to the Ministry of Health’s information system in accordance with personal data protection legislation; camera and microphone access permissions; that the service may be ended at any time by informing the other party; that the person providing the healthcare is responsible for the security of the IT systems; and the nature and consequences of the service.
2. Manner of Informing
As a rule, the patient must be informed personally. If the patient requests that someone else be informed instead, information is given only to the persons designated, provided that the request is recorded in writing with the patient’s signature. Where consent is to be given by the patient’s legal or appointed representative, those persons must be informed.
Information is provided in an appropriate setting and with due regard to the patient’s privacy.
3. Security of the Patient’s Personal Data
This information must include the data subject’s rights set out in Article 11 of Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698 (KVKK). Accordingly, the patient must be informed of whether their personal data is processed and, if so, for what purpose; the third parties to whom it is transferred; that their personal data may be erased or destroyed upon request; the right to request that the correction, erasure or destruction of personal data be notified to third parties to whom the data was transferred; the right to object to an adverse outcome resulting from analysis of the processed data exclusively by automated systems; and the right to claim compensation for damage suffered due to unlawful processing of their data.
Administrative Sanctions
The sanctions applicable to healthcare facilities or personnel that fail to comply with the standards for remote healthcare are listed in Annex 2 (EK-2) of the Regulation. Accordingly:
- If a healthcare facility provides remote healthcare without permission from the Ministry, its remote healthcare activity is immediately stopped by the Governorship.
- If the facility provides services in a field for which it is not authorised, it is warned on the first finding and given 1 month. On a second finding, remote healthcare is suspended for 10 days, and the healthcare professional who provided the service without authorisation is not permitted to provide remote healthcare for 1 month. On a third finding, the facility’s remote healthcare authorisation certificate is revoked, and no new application may be filed for 1 year. If the person providing unauthorised remote healthcare is the same as at the second finding, that person is not permitted to provide remote healthcare for 1 year.
- If a service other than those listed in the Regulation is provided, the facility is warned on the first and second findings and given 1 month. On a third finding, remote healthcare is suspended for 10 days, and the healthcare professional who provided the service without authorisation is not permitted to provide it for 1 month. On a fourth finding, the facility’s remote healthcare certificate is revoked, and no new application may be filed for 1 year.
- If the service is provided by a healthcare professional for whom no work certificate has been issued, the facility is warned on the first finding and given 1 month. On a second finding, remote healthcare is suspended for 10 days, and the healthcare professional who provided the service without authorisation is not permitted to provide remote healthcare for 1 month. On a third finding, the facility’s remote healthcare authorisation certificate is revoked, and no new application may be filed for 1 year. If the person providing unauthorised remote healthcare is the same as at the second finding, that person is not permitted to provide remote healthcare for 1 year.
- If persons not qualified to practise their profession in Türkiye provide remote healthcare at the facility, on the first finding the service is suspended and a criminal complaint is filed with the Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office against the person concerned. On a second finding, the activity is suspended, an administrative fine equal to one percent of the facility’s gross service revenue for the previous month is imposed, and a criminal complaint is filed against the person concerned. On a third finding, the facility’s remote healthcare certificate is revoked, and no new application may be filed for 1 year.
- If a device other than medical devices registered by the Turkish Medicines and Medical Devices Agency is used, the facility is warned on the first and second findings and given one month. On a third finding, remote healthcare is suspended for 10 days, and the healthcare professional who provided the service without authorisation is not permitted to provide remote healthcare for 1 month. On a further finding, the facility’s remote healthcare authorisation certificate is revoked, and no new application may be filed for 1 year.
Sanctions for Breach of the Duty to Inform
In the following cases of breach of the duty to inform, the facility is warned and given one month on the first and second findings; on the third finding, remote healthcare is suspended for ten days; on the fourth finding, the facility’s remote healthcare authorisation certificate is revoked, and no new application may be filed for one year:
-
if information is not provided in accordance with Article 9/1 of the Regulation,
-
if the necessary measures to verify the identity of the person receiving the service are not taken,
-
if the necessary measures under Article 11 of the Regulation and the Regulation on Patient Rights are not taken,
-
if the facility does not store data in accordance with the KVKK and secondary legislation,
-
if the healthcare services provided are recorded on video or audio, or photographs are taken during the service, without the explicit consent of the parties.
In the following cases of breach of the duty to inform, the authorisation certificate is revoked on the third finding, and no new application may be filed for one year:
-
if video and audio recordings are not stored in secure data centres approved by the Ministry,
-
if, where the work and procedures relating to remote healthcare for persons applying to the facility are recorded digitally, they are not transferred to the central health data system in accordance with the procedures and principles determined by the Ministry,
-
if information and documents requested by the Ministry are not sent to it.
The number of findings of non-compliance with the Regulation is determined on the basis of a one-year period, which starts on the date of the first finding.
Conclusion
The provision of healthcare through telemedicine is an important development that increases the accessibility of modern healthcare, enabling patients to reach treatment effectively and efficiently, and aiming to lighten the workload of healthcare professionals and help them practise their professions more efficiently. Turkish legislation on remote healthcare aims to ensure that these services, which differ considerably from ordinary healthcare, are provided within certain standards, thereby protecting patients’ rights and ensuring the supervision of healthcare institutions. Where remote healthcare is supported by artificial intelligence, informing patients and protecting personal data falling within the “special categories of data” are particularly important. For this reason, failure to comply with the relevant legislation in the provision of remote healthcare is subject to serious sanctions. It is of great importance that healthcare institutions providing remote healthcare carry out their activities in compliance with the relevant legislation.
Bibliography
Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698
World Health Organization (WHO), Global strategy on digital health 2020–2025, https://iris.who.int/bitstream/handle/10665/364221/9789240059184-eng.pdf?sequence=1
Regulation on the Provision of Remote Healthcare Services, Official Gazette No. 31746 dated 10.02.2022, https://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/eskiler/2022/02/20220210-2.htm
DOĞRAMACI, Y.G., Teletıp, Sağlık Turizmi ve Uzaktan Sağlık Hizmetleri: Mesafeli Sözleşmeler, İstanbul Hukuk Mecmuası, 78 (2), 657-710, 2020, https://dergipark.org.tr/en/download/article-file/1351701
Personal Data Protection Authority (KVKK), Rights of the data subject, https://www.kvkk.gov.tr/Icerik/2036/Ilgili-Kisinin-Haklari
BADUR, E., Uzaktan Sağlık Hizmeti Sözleşmesi, Research Article, Hacettepe HFD, 12(2), 2022, 1162-1199, https://dergipark.org.tr/tr/download/article-file/2643069
Kotil, Z. Ö., Kişisel Verilerin Korunması Çerçevesinde Yapay Zeka, (2022), On İki Levha Yayıncılık.
Akalın, B., & Veranyurt, Ü. (2021). Sağlık hizmetleri ve yönetiminde yapay zekâ. Acta Infologica, 5(1), 231-240. https://doi.org/10.26650/acin.850857
This article is for general information only. The outcome of a specific matter may vary depending on its facts.




